Loading...
Check-in - Check-out Date
2 Adults - 0 Children

Sanibel Family Vacation Tradition: A Historic Guest Story at the Island Inn

Sanibel Family Vacation Tradition: A Historic Guest Story at the Island Inn

 In the Fall of 1951 Dr. & Mrs. A. W. Rappole began their written correspondence with the Island Inn regarding their first family vacation to Sanibel Island.  The Rappole’s, with two or possibly three of their children, desired a respite from the cold winters in their hometown of Jamestown, New York to the warm, sunny island of Sanibel, off the Southwest coast of Florida. As noted in one of their early inquires, the Rappole family chose Sanibel and the Island Inn because of their 11-year old son’s interest in growing his ‘extensive shell collection.’ The Inn’s founders, Will & Harriett (Granny) Matthews, were some of Sanibel Island’s first and most famous shell enthusiasts.  In fact, the Matthew’s chose the geographic location of the Island Inn because of its beach’s prime southern exposure, which acts as a natural shovel, scooping up shells that the currents bring from the deeper waters of the Gulf of Mexico.

Our eleven-year old boy has already acquired quite an extensive shell collection and it is for this reason we are particularly interested in spending some time at Sanibel.

As it was standard to communicate via post mail in the early 1950’s, Dr. Rappole and the Inn’s manager at the time, Ed Borchers, continued their correspondence over the next 3 months – exchanging dates, rates and other necessary details in an attempt to finalize accommodations for the family’s seashell-inspired vacation. Dr. Rappole’s initial request, full room and board for the last two weeks of February, was unavailable. However, the Inn responded with a winter rate card along with other availability options, helping guide the Rappole’s to ultimately make their first trip to Sanibel Island.

island inn historic rate sheet

This historic rate sheet was mailed to inquiring guests looking to book a vacation in the early 1950’s

Dr. Rappole’s written response was for a 4-bedroom cottage with private bathroom for $260 per week or, as a second choice, two rooms in “the Inn proper” with shared bathroom for $220 per week.  Dr. Rappole elaborated that the family would be traveling via a Constellation plane from Cleveland and landing in Tampa.  Final transportation to Sanibel Island would be made via mail or ferry boat from either Fort Myers or Punta Rassa.

On January 18, 1952, Borchers confirmed the Rappole’s first stay at the Island Inn, a double-room in “The Barracks”.  Borchers further informed Dr. Rappole that their late morning arrival into Fort Myers would not allow them to catch the 8 AM mail boat, but that they should plan on catching the early afternoon ferry. Borchers instructed Dr. Rappole to call the Inn from the Sanibel Island ferry landing and he would then arrange their speedy pick up. Thus the start of multi-generational visits to the Island Inn by the Rappole family.

Mail boat leaves Fort Myers at 8 A.M. daily except Sunday, and therefore your arrival in Fort Myers in the late morning will not allow you to use this boat to get to Sanibel. Suggest that you taxi to Punta Rassa, where the ferry leaves for the Island, and we will meet you on the Sanibel Side.

Five years and various Rappole vacations later, Charlotta Matthews, niece to Granny Matthews, informed Doctor Rappole that the Inn was being sold to some of its longtime guests. While she ensured that their future stays would be equally comfortable, she hinted that becoming a “member of the club” would provide additional benefits. Today, 1st, 2nd, 3rd and even 4th generations of these early Island Inn guests make up the Inn’s Shareholders.

charolette matthews letter to guest

Charoletta Matthews, niece to Inn founder Granny Matthews, was also know as Miss Charolette and famous for her Tea Room

The Rappole’s family vacation visits to the Island Inn continued into the future, returning each year for the children’s spring break. With school schedules having a yearly impact on their desired travel dates, the Island Inn continued its correspondence with the Rappole’s, creating a lasting relationship for generations to come.

Sixty-four years later, families just like the Rappole’s continue to book their annual excursion to the Island Inn, but with much more ease via online reservations or our toll-free phone line.  We invite your family to become part of our history in the making!

Cherished memories, modern comforts.  Enjoy it all at the Island Inn!

Hotels & Suites

Modern rooms and suits, all within yards of the warm Sanibel Island beaches.

AMENITIES

Featuring 550’ of pristine beach, onsite bikes and kayaks, free WiFi & much more!

You Might Also Like:

Sanibel Thanksgiving

Sanibel Thanksgiving We've put together the following list for Thanksgiving dining, activity & worship happenings taking place on Sanibel & Captiva on Thanksgiving day. Make sure to check with each vendor for specific details. If you would like to submit a...

A Day in the Life of an Island Inn Guest

A Day in the Life of an Island Inn Guest https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgc2RjH4-W0 Experience a day in the life of a guest at the Island Inn on Sanibel Island. Adventure on-site & later explore all the islands have to offer, post Hurricane Ian. From kayaking in...

What Businesses Are Open on Sanibel Island?

What Businesses Are Open on Sanibel Island? Florida's Sanibel Island took a large toll from Hurricane Ian, but business are bouncing back and "The Island" is returning to the beautiful tropical getaway you remember. Is it perfect? No. Is it still paradise? Absolutely!...

The First of Any Open Hotels on Sanibel Island

The First of Any Open Hotels on Sanibel Island     Photo taken December 2022 Information for Guests – Know Before You Go! The Island Inn reopened its doors as the first hotel on Sanibel Island to receive guests post-Hurricane Ian. Thanks to major capital...

Hurricane Ian

Matthews Lodge at the Island Inn standing strong & proud after the eye-wall of Hurricane Ian crossed over Sanibel Island on September 28, 2022 To our loyal guests who have shown unwavering love and compassion for our historic piece of paradise, First and foremost,...

American Innovators Tied to Historic Sanibel Hotel

American Innovators Tied to Historic Sanibel Hotel While we've always known our cherished Island Inn has great history, it's always exciting when we unveil new pieces to our quaint, beachfront puzzle. One of these most recent instances pertains to our Phister Cottage....

The Island Inn highlights Mangroves and the Sanibel Captiva Conservation Foundation

The Island Inn highlights Mangroves and the Sanibel Captiva Conservation FoundationAs the Islands' oldest hotel, the Island Inn shares a common goal with local environmental organizations of preserving the well-being of our estuaries, the health of our local ecology,...

Wall Street Journal: Florida’s Best Beaches

Wall Street Journal: Florida’s Best Beaches The Island Inn, Sanibel's #1 hotel & inn, was named in the Wall Street Journal for Florida's BEST beaches! We are incredibly proud of this recognition and definitely agree that our 550ft of pristine beachfront checks all...

What airport is closest to Sanibel Island and Island Inn?

What airport is closest to Sanibel Island and Island Inn?If you have recently booked a stay with the Island Inn on Sanibel Island, you probably wonder what airport is closest to Sanibel Island. This is a common question, particularly for guests arriving from outside...

What is the best travel insurance for Florida beach resorts?

What is the best travel insurance for Florida beach resorts?The past several years of the COVID-19 pandemic have taught us all that travel plans are never a sure thing. No matter how much we want to enjoy a vacation getaway to a beautiful island, there is no promise...

Where to Stay: Pet-Friendly Hotels on Sanibel Island

Where to Stay: Pet-Friendly Hotels on Sanibel IslandWhile the Island Inn does not accept pets, we are always pleased to refer visitors to Sanibel Island hotels and resorts that are pet-friendly. In fact, you have plenty of options here if you wish to travel with your...

On my way to Island Inn, will I pay a Sanibel Causeway toll?

On my way to Island Inn, will I pay a Sanibel Causeway toll?One of the most common questions we hear at the Island Inn Sanibel is, “How much is the toll for the Sanibel Causeway?” Other booking guests ask whether there is a Sanibel Causeway toll discount. Thankfully,...

Sanibel Christmas and New Year’s Activities, Services + Restaurant Hours

Sanibel Christmas and New Year’s Activities, Services + Restaurant Hours It's the most wonderful time of the year and we want our guests to know all things holiday related on Sanibel & Captiva Islands. Below you will find current information on Sanibel Christmas...

Newest Vacation Rental Homes on Sanibel Island

Newest Vacation Rental Homes on Sanibel Island Sanibel Island has become one of the most sought after destination in the world because of its peaceful atmosphere, pristine beaches and world-class seashell collecting! And as its popularity has grown, the Island Inn has...

Luminary Festival

The Sanibel Luminary is quite the holiday scene each year on our beautiful, tropical island. The Sanibel & Captiva Islands Chamber of Commerce event will be taking place in traditional fashion on Friday, December 5th! Enjoy a fun-filled evening of holiday cheer,...

Thanksgiving on Sanibel

We’ve collected the below information for our guests to make your Sanibel Thanksgiving holiday with the Island Inn the best experience possible. Church Services Captiva Chapel by the Sea – Outdoor Thanksgiving Eve Service 11580 Chapin Lane - 4PM Saint Michael &...

The Perfect Beach is Within Driving Distance

The Perfect Beach is Within Driving Distance   A Guide for Driving to Sanibel Island Sanibel Island is the perfect drive-to destination for people looking for a tropical, secluded beach vacation, without having to deal with the hassle of booking airline flights....

Island Inn Family Vacation Guide on Sanibel Island

Island Inn Family Vacation Guide on Sanibel IslandSanibel Island is a great place to vacation with your family. From shelling on the beach, biking paths, and various guided and boat tours, there are activities and places to visit for families of any size and children...

The 83rd Annual Shell Festival Is Almost Here!

The 83rd Annual Shell Festival Is Almost Here!The 83rd Annual Sanibel Shell Festival will take place at the Sanibel Community House in just over a week! From March 5th – March 7th see what amazing shell seekers do with all of their wonderful shells they find on our...

Turtles at the Island Inn

Turtles at the Island Inn Have you ever walked along the shores of Sanibel and noticed one of these? Sea turtle nest at the Island Inn These staked-off sections are where sea turtles have made their nests! As part of our ongoing efforts to be stewards of the...

Support the Shell Museum for a chance to WIN GOLD from Congress Jewelers

Support the Shell Museum for a chance to WIN GOLD from Congress Jewelers Support the Shell Museum for a chance to WIN GOLD from Congress Jewelers 14K White or Yellow Gold Sand Dollar, Starfish, Pectin shell pendant with .05 ct. Round Diamond set in Sand Dollar ($595...

Best Hotel Sanibel Has to Offer! Island Inn Wins 2022 Award for ‘Best Of’…

Best Hotel Sanibel Has to Offer! Island Inn Wins 2022 Award for ‘Best Of’…NOTICE: Some information on these pages are pre-Hurricane Ian and may not be fully up-to-date. Wondering what the best hotel Sanibel has to offer is? The Island Inn was recently awarded the 2022...

Sanibel Island Family Activities

Sanibel Island Family Activities There are a great deal of things to do on Sanibel Island when traveling with a family. Activities that appeal to kids of all ages from babies to toddlers to teenagers and beyond. Sanibel Island is a great place to vacation with a...

Ellie and Jared Visit Sanibel

Ellie and Jared Visit SanibelThis past May, the Island Inn hosted our friends Ellie and Jared Mecham. Ellie and Jared spent lots of time with their family learning all about Sanibel and all the amazing things to do while vacationing on our beautiful island. We've...

Where is Sanibel Island?

Where is Sanibel Island?NOTICE: Some information on these pages are pre-Hurricane Ian and may not be fully up-to-date. Sanibel is nestled in a strand of barrier islands that spans the Gulf shores of the west coast of FL from Fort Myers to Boca Grande, and is one of...

Sanibel Island Easter Events & Services

Sanibel Island Easter Events & Services For the benefit of our guests we have compiled a list of scheduled activities taking place on or around Sanibel and Captiva over the holiday weekend. Please note, the Island Inn is not hosting an Easter event this year....

How to See Sanibel Island Dolphins

Take a dolphin watching tour. To your advantage, dolphin tour operators are often “locals” who know the most likely places and times for observing dolphins.

How to Choose a Sanibel Island Cottage

There are many cottages on Sanibel Island; your choice says a lot about you and the kind of vacation traveler you are. Ask yourself: Am I happiest when I am among my friends and new acquaintances in a restaurant or night club? Or do I mostly look forward to spending hours under a palm tree – or walking on nature trails by myself? Fortunately, the Island Inn is a convenient choice for both of these approaches to leisure.

A Day in the Life of an Island Inn Guest

I am really looking forward to our first day at Island Inn on Sanibel Island. We arrived last evening just after dark and were tired from our long drive. Boy is it quiet here; don’t know why I woke up. It’s still dark outside and my wife is still asleep. I guess I’m just used to getting up early.

We left the windows open while we slept. I’m glad we did that because I love breathing that beautiful salt air! I can just barely hear the waves sloshing on the shore. It sure is a relaxing sound – maybe I’ll just lay back and listen for a few minutes while I decide what to do next…

Sanibel Island Florida: Paradise on the Gulf

Imagine an island retreat nestled in the warm, tranquil waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Picture a destination big enough to offer a variety of exciting activities and opportunities for solitude, but small enough to avoid the hassle of the sprawling resort towns. In your imagination you just conjured up Sanibel Island Florida, truly a jewel in the Gulf region.

Visitor Reviews

5 star rating Shelley’s paradise This is our second time at the Island Inn. First time was before Ian. The place has changed with the removal of the central building that held the restaurant but the accommodation and people are the same. It’s a great location right on the beach. We stayed for a week for my wife’s birthday and they left her a special treat. Great people and great place. Highly recommend
read more
David 1/23/2025
media thumbnail 0media thumbnail 1media thumbnail 2
5 star rating After Ian Still recovering from hurricane Ian we knew in advance that amenities were limited. Our room was great, very clean and comfortable, the management are doing the best they can for visitors. Very welcoming and friendly, and if you understand how bad that hurricane was I still recommend this place. There is building work noise nearby but we expected that. This place will bounce back and we would definitely stay there again in the future.
read more
CaptainswifeCannes 1/19/2025
5 star rating Love the Island Inn! We have been coming to Sanibel for years and this was our first stay at the Island Inn. We booked again for next year before we left, we love it there. Wonderful and easy accommodations, great helpful staff, we couldn't ask for anything more. You step right onto the beach from your screened in porch, so even when you are not on the beach you are enjoying it. The best shelling around! We enjoyed the morning beach walk with the staff from the Sanibel Sea School, it was very knowledgable and fun! Highly recommend!
read more
tracy 1/17/2025
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.

Don't Miss An Update

Sign up for our monthly newsletter for the latest updates, news, and offers.